Post your favorite Pizza Place

[Spivitz]

White Cottage aka Pizza Kitchen in Roselle too

 

[Lead Pipe]

White Cottage in Elgin is solid.

 

[CMNTMXR57]

I forgot, I like the Old Town location in Elgin too. I can't speak to the other locations... Although the owner, Mike just sold it to another family. I can't say it's quite the same.

One of the benefits of working there, is I eat free. Between slices that we can't sell any more, fuck-ups, or customers not coming to get their pizzas or us not being able to deliver them, we eat good.

The other night, we had a customer not pick up a modified "Texan" pizza. It is a pizza with BBQ sauce instead of pizza sauce, sausage, onions and bacon (real bacon, not that canadian bacon ham shit). Anyway, the customer changed out the sausage for pepperoni and didn't do the onions. FUCK was that good! The sweetness and tanginess of the bbq sauce offset the saltiness/spiciness of the pepperoni, and then that pepperoni and the bacon added a shit ton of grease which added some flavor in it's own right.

 

[Sprayin]

I haven’t. Always thin crust from them. I’ll order Lou’s if I want deep dish here. There’s no shortage of pizza places around here. I’d say 8 within a three block radius of my domicile.

8 within 3 blocks? Fuck, I miss Chicago sometimes.

 

[OffshoreDrilling]

8 within 3 blocks? Fuck, I miss Chicago sometimes.

 

[Gav'sPurpleZ]

when I lived in the city, we always ordered from Pete's Pizzeria @ 5847 W Montrose.

Now that we are in the burbs, I would say White Cottage in Elgin.
The Rosatti's in Gilberts is solid and then there's also Maciano's in Elgin.

 

[EmersonHart13]

Keep 'em coming. I am going to make an effort to try some of these pies....

 

[Bruce Jibboo]

White Cottage also has a place in Elgin on Randall.

Another we like is Danny's on Douglas over by the police station in Elgin. Much like White Cottage, they put plenty of cheese on it, so don't need to ask for extra. Their cheddar cheese poppers are also an excellent appetizer, and believe it or not, their fried chicken is great.

I see Nicks mentioned. Nicks and Village are two brothers. One (Nick Sarilla... I think that's his last name), owns Nick's and then the other brother who's name escapes me right now, owns Village. When you go there, you gotta get the double decker pizza. It's basically two thin crust pizzas stacked on top of one another.

And of course, I gotta plug my place. Charlie Fox's in Geneva. There are also a St. Charles with a dining room and a Batavia location, which like us is take out or delivery.

Charlie Fox's Pizza – Geneva |

One of my first jobs was at the Village in Carpentersville so that owner is Mike Sarillo who also owns the Village on Randall north of 90, then its his nephew Nick that owns the Nicks Pizza in Crystal Lake, Elgin, and now one in Chicago. I "think" I still call both those my favorites. The pizza's between the two are very close based on the family recipe.

 

[Sprayin]

Houston suckkkkkkkkkssssss

 

[EmersonHart13]

Mook is jealous

 

[Mook]

The holy trinity

 

[CMNTMXR57]

One of my first jobs was at the Village in Carpentersville so that owner is Mike Sarillo who also owns the Village on Randall north of 90, then its his nephew Nick that owns the Nicks Pizza in Crystal Lake, Elgin, and now one in Chicago. I "think" I still call both those my favorites. The pizza's between the two are very close based on the family recipe.

Sorry, I took them as brothers.

Yup, almost identical. Both excellent.

The sausage double decker I think is my fav there.

 

[Sprayin]

The holy trinity

I get dominos and PH fairly often here because it's really all there is in terms of cheapish pizza.

 

[Kensington]

I worked for Lou's for 9ish years. Still love their pizza. If I need reliable deep dish, locally, I'm going there. Elk Grove probably is the best of their locations I've been to (as far as the quality goes)

That being said, if I have my choice of favorites, Pequod's. Morton Grove or city, I haven't really noticed that big of a difference between the two other than the city location being much roomier to sit in.

 

[Egreen99]

This place was a pleasant surprise.. thin crust

Joes Pizza
530 W Wise Rd, Schaumburg, IL 60193

 

[Fish]

I've gotta add one more...especially for the dine-in experience.

I don't get up that way much anymore, but this place is amazing. Pizza is outstanding (try the double decker pizza), unlimited peanuts and you throw shells on the ground, video arcade for the kids, and probably a hundred stuffed animals on the walls (coyotes, birds, raccoons, even a bear, etc.). Most importantly, some of the best tasting tap beer I've ever had.

Bill's Pizza & Pub
624 South Lake Street Mundelein, IL 60060
(847) 566-5380

Ive gotten the double decker for my guys at work a couple times. Its still enjoyable.

We usually do Giordanos bar style (thin crust) and Nardis in Addison.

 

[Shawn1112]

when I lived in the city, we always ordered from Pete's Pizzeria @ 5847 W Montrose.

Now that we are in the burbs, I would say White Cottage in Elgin.
The Rosatti's in Gilberts is solid and then there's also Maciano's in Elgin.

Same owners as Petes on Western just north of Addison?
If so Pete's is awesome

 

[Gav'sPurpleZ]

I'm not sure.... could be ?

 

[03GTGreen]

Come the fuck on, really???

Ya rly, their meat lovers is delicious

 

[LikeABauce302]

I need to try Rosangela's. I live a half mile away and half never been there.

 

[EmersonHart13]

I need to try Rosangela's. I live a half mile away and half never been there.

It's worth a half mile. I grew up down the street. What's your go to Barracos?

 

[LikeABauce302]

It's worth a half mile. I grew up down the street. What's your go to Barracos?

Palermo's has always been my go to. I've never been a fan of Barracos.

 

[jbigalow]

Casey's General store
Location - Any Casey's gas station

Pequod's Pizza
Morton Grove.

 

[EmersonHart13]

Palermo's has always been my go to. I've never been a fan of Barracos.

Tatas on 111th east of kedzie makes a nice piece, sweet sauce which is unique.

My Dad is big on Waldo Cooney's as well

Ever get Beggars? WI approved. Lol

 

[Great White Drake]

Fasanos FUCK errthing else. 83rd and Roberts rd in bridgeview.