On the plus side:
Ease of use. Turn it on. Insert food and wood chips. Relax.
Decent smoke flavor.
If you wrap the water and drain pans with foil, clean up isn't hard.
On the negative:
No smoke ring (not enough oxygen?)
Masterbuilt wood chip tray is too small and requires refilling hourly.
Masterbuilt thermometer is 25 degrees high. Set it at 275* and the grill will be at 250* and 275 is as high as it goes.
30" size doesn't have a ton of room. Need to cut rib racks in half so they fit. You can manipulate the smoker racks to allow for things like brisket by angling one rack down so you have its surface area connecting to a lower rack's surface area. Not elegant but it works.
Overall, I think the Masterbuilt is a good choice if you don't want to babysit your smoker. It won't give results as good as an offset smoker but it does OK. Will I buy one? Too early to tell. Hopefully my buddy lets me keep it a couple more weeks so I can try a pork butt and maybe a turkey in it.
Ease of use. Turn it on. Insert food and wood chips. Relax.
Decent smoke flavor.
If you wrap the water and drain pans with foil, clean up isn't hard.
On the negative:
No smoke ring (not enough oxygen?)
Masterbuilt wood chip tray is too small and requires refilling hourly.
Masterbuilt thermometer is 25 degrees high. Set it at 275* and the grill will be at 250* and 275 is as high as it goes.
30" size doesn't have a ton of room. Need to cut rib racks in half so they fit. You can manipulate the smoker racks to allow for things like brisket by angling one rack down so you have its surface area connecting to a lower rack's surface area. Not elegant but it works.
Overall, I think the Masterbuilt is a good choice if you don't want to babysit your smoker. It won't give results as good as an offset smoker but it does OK. Will I buy one? Too early to tell. Hopefully my buddy lets me keep it a couple more weeks so I can try a pork butt and maybe a turkey in it.