I thought the writers did a bad job with this episode.
Look at the end resuts (spoilers)
Kelly and Bortus kill a BUNCH of aliens. Even if the new star appears, didn't they just kill a bunch of people? Seems that might be a crime on a planet where they lock up people based on a zodiac sign because they MIGHT commit violence. Isn't the actual crime worse?
Everyone on the Orville thinks it's a great idea to put up fake news and mess with the beliefs of an entire planet to get their people back and change the alien society. What happens if, when the planet finds out the truth, they have a major civil war that kills millions? First Directive and all that. (I know that's StarTrek but...)
It's left wing crapoganda saying the ends justify the means. Who makes the choice? A Captain and First Officer? Interfering in a planet's culture and beliefs? That's a hell of a lot worse than sending Isaac in with a shuttle and grabbing them.
I can see Mercer's report: Well, we didn't send in one guy to steal them back but we did disrupt an entire planetary belief system because we felt it was wrong. So, we're good, right?
Disappointing.
Look at the end resuts (spoilers)
Kelly and Bortus kill a BUNCH of aliens. Even if the new star appears, didn't they just kill a bunch of people? Seems that might be a crime on a planet where they lock up people based on a zodiac sign because they MIGHT commit violence. Isn't the actual crime worse?
Everyone on the Orville thinks it's a great idea to put up fake news and mess with the beliefs of an entire planet to get their people back and change the alien society. What happens if, when the planet finds out the truth, they have a major civil war that kills millions? First Directive and all that. (I know that's StarTrek but...)
It's left wing crapoganda saying the ends justify the means. Who makes the choice? A Captain and First Officer? Interfering in a planet's culture and beliefs? That's a hell of a lot worse than sending Isaac in with a shuttle and grabbing them.
I can see Mercer's report: Well, we didn't send in one guy to steal them back but we did disrupt an entire planetary belief system because we felt it was wrong. So, we're good, right?
Disappointing.