Regardless of what you do, you will have a great time. Disney knows how to provide fun. I think Great America's rides are actually better but Disney's build up blows Great America away. Great America has a theme oriented building facade to look at while you are in line. Disney builds the whole building.
+100
Disney had so much more attention to detail, GA doesn't even compare. I remember the log rides @ GA, wait in line... go on a little trip and then climb up and go down. Disney's Splash Mountain took you through a theme w/ plenty to look @ before you went down, and even after that, more to look at. Definitely Disney knows how to provide fun.
Problem with staying off site is that you can't stay late at whichever park that is open late each evening. Might not matter as much with smaller kids but our kids loved the extra hours with not so many people.
We never made it up late at night, we went back around 9:00 ~ 10:00 every night to recharge for the next day. Getting to the park early was key to getting some good rides in and early fast passes.
Tower of Terror [a little scary for little kids but fun], Buzz Lightyear is great for kids, Soarin' is awesome for everyone, Mission Space gives some G forces but is really cool if the kids and wife can handle it, Honey I shrunk the kids is fun for little kids although watch out when they get stung in their seats, Dinosaur was wild, the wildlife train was OK if you want to quietly see some animals.
We did every ride we wanted at all (4) parks + both water parks and Disney quest. The only ride we missed was space mountain @ the kingdom. The lines were reasonable (And July is supposed to be the busiest month). With the fast pass, most lines were only minutes.
Tuesday Morning - Tinley Park - Crestwood Shuttle - ORD - MCO - Mustang Convertible Rental.
Tuesday Noon - Epcot
Tuesday Evening - Rental Home + Swim in Pool
Wednesday - Animal Kingdom + Disney Quest
Thursday - Typhoon Lagoon + Disney Quest
Friday - Magic Kingdom
Saturday - MGM / Disney Studios
Sunday - Epcot
Monday - Blizzard Beach + Downtown Disney
Tuesday - Return Home (I4 Hassle)
One thing we noticed about Disney is how clean the park is. You don't see trash anywhere. You don't see chipped, peeling paint, you don't see worn out rides, etc. Even attractions that are 20+ years old are still maintained in good condition and look like new. Everything looks good. We saw two Disney Employee's doing water fountain check (Using a check sheet) and they spotted a piece of gum on the ground. Even though it probably wasn't their job to clean it, they carefully scrapped it up and spent several minutes getting it all off of the pavement.
You don't see delivery trucks going into / out of Disney property, yet they must have hundreds of trucks shipping in merchandise and food every day. This is all done behind the scenes, perhaps @ night, to add to the magic @ Disney.
Dining @ Disney is not too expensive if you stick to the one $ restaurants. Generally we brought in Frozen water bottles to the park along with snacks and either ate a light lunch in the park or ate in the parking lot. We later found that we could bring in our own sandwiches into the park.
We did the 7-day Park Hopper w/ The Water Park Fun @ More Option. We bought the tickets online before we left and saved a small amount of money. We bought them from
http://reserveorlando.com/. Other web sites seemed to all be priced the same w/ above site beating other web site prices by about $20/each.
We rented this house for $110 a night.
http://www.vacationbythemouse.com/16622highgrove.htm. I figured it was about the same price to rent a house as two hotel rooms. Never got to use the pool that much, Disney wore us out pretty well. House was only one or two years old, very clean, good condition. House had 4 bedrooms (2 Master Bedroom Kings + 2 Twin Bedrooms w/ (2) beds each) for a total of (6) beds. It could easily accommodate two families.
I wanted to do some dinner shows, but there was no time. It was a 100% Disney vacation, other than for staying off Disney property.
I got a spreadsheet comparing prices for dinner shows from different vendors as well as Disney ticket prices if anyone is interested. You will save money if you compare prices before you buy.
Breakdown estimate on cost
Airfare for (4) - $832 (Orbitz)
House with tax - $862 (Check)
Disney Tickets 7 Days (3) Adult, (1) Child - $1166
Groceries, etc @ Publix - $120 +/-
Crestwood Shuttle - $56 Roundtrip for (2) adult + (2) Child
Souvenirs - $200 Est.
Mustang Convertible 7 Days - $350 (Could have been $305 w/ Payless)
Gas - $40 Est.
Park Money - $150 ~ $200 Est.
Total - About 4K