I'm looking for a new DD and would like to get better MPG's. I won't go japanese and every American small car up to 2008 is a shitbox. I have been looking at early-mid 2000's Jetta and Golf 1.8t's. Any opinions on them? Things to stay away from, major problems? I commute about 50 miles per day so the miles will add up pretty quick.
I feel like most Golf's/Jetta's in that time frame are just like the Cobalt SS I owned... GREAT power plant, killer aftermarket, and CAN get ok mileage, but the rest of the car is honestly fairly crappy and unreliable....
HONESTLY, go look at 2005-2007 Ford Focus's... (I think the interior in the 08-10's is HORRID, and the 00-04 ones are great cars, but the 05-07's are quite a bit better in every regard (Styling/Interior/Refinement/Etc) and worth the small premium over the 00-04 ones IMO)
I put 42K miles on my 2007 focus (auto) in 2 and a half years after buying it new. Changed the oil, gave it gas, replaced the tires at 36K, and nothing more. Interior is nothing to write home about, but I feel it was far better and more spacious feeling than anything comparable (I test drove a Neon/Caliber/Cobalt/Civic back then)
No rattles, everything had good fit, and great erganomics, a bit plasticy, but thats typical for cheap domestics...
I got 30-33 mpg basically no matter how or where I drove it. I think they've aged well, and have very 'non-offensive' styling, but aren't overly bland.
Found easily in 5 speed, and typically came with a 136hp/136tq motor (2.0 Duratech), has far more pickup than a comparable entry level civic/corolla/cobalt/etc.
You can find "ST" trim ones for great prices now as well (170hp 2.3 Duratech, came only as 5 speed sedans, and are typically fairly loaded *Heated seats, sunroof, etc*)
My 2007 SE Sedan:
Interior:
And before anyone else does it