đź“° Auto News Official Cash for Clunkers trade-in list reveals oddities too strange to believe

EmersonHart13

TCG Elite Member
TCG Premium
Jul 18, 2007
54,215
22,341
Official Cash for Clunkers trade-in list reveals oddities too strange to believe

by Frank Filipponio (RSS feed) on Sep 24th 2009 at 12:58PM

Cash for Clunkers claimed some really interesting vehicles - Was a Buick GNX among them?

Mixed reaction has surrounded the government's Cash for Clunkers program, but after spending around $2.8 billion, some 700,000 new vehicles have found homes. But what got traded in? We've heard some horror stories, but now that the full list of executed vehicles has been released on the Cars.gov website and we've listed some of the oddities we found while snooping around. Many are down right hard to believe, suggesting either errors in the submission process, typos in the list or even some fudging by dealers who clunked a few vehicles that weren't eligible. After the jump is a list of "Clunkers" that stood out. We can't guarantee these all really went to the crusher, but they do appear on the list.

Follow the jump for a recap of the program's eligibility requirements for trade-in vehicles and our full list. And we'd suggest having a box of tissues nearby.

[Source: Cars.gov]

We've outlined the rules of the government's Consumer Assistance to Recycle and Save Act of 2009 (CARS) program before, but we think a refresher is warranted before you browse the list below. Customers were able to bring in an old "clunker" no older than model year 1984 that got, at most, 18 mpg if they were buying a new vehicle with better mpg. That trade-in had to be in running condition and insured for at least one year prior to the trade. A rebate of $3,500-$4,500 for the trade was applied towards a new car purchase based on the difference in mpg between the old and the new vehicle. Dealers did most of the work, verifying the eligibility of the traded vehicle and seeing to it that the old cars were properly disposed of. That included disabling the engine and guaranteeing the cars were shredded before the government refunded the money.

NOTE: We find it hard to believe that many vehicles in the list below were actually destroyed through the Cash for Clunkers program, and while they may be officially on the list, their inclusion is more likely explained by an error in the submission process, typos or dealerships that managed to game the system.


Individual Vehicles

  • 1987 Buick ASC GNX
  • 1997 Aston Martin DB7 Volante
  • 1997 Bentley Continental R
  • 1989 20th Anniversary Pontiac Trans Am
  • 1992 GMC Typhoon (no!)
  • 1985 Audi Quattro
  • 1992 BMW 850i
  • 2006 Audi A4 Convertible
  • 2006 Cadillac STS
  • 2008 Foose F-150 (2)
  • 2007 GMC Acadias (3)
  • 2008 Hyundai Accent (see above)
  • 2006 Nissan 350Z Roadster
  • 2006 Roush Stage 3 F-150 (2)
  • 2006 Toyota Corolla
  • 2005 Mazda RX-8
  • 2002 Kia Spectra
  • 1988 Aurora Cobra kit car
  • 1996 Buick Funeral Coaches/Hearses
  • 1987 Duntov GT
  • 1987 Excalibur Autos Phaeton
  • 1990 Honda CRX (Less than 18 mpg?)
  • 1985 Maserati Quattroporte
  • 1999 Mercedes C43 AMG
  • 1985 TVR 280i convertible

Groupings

  • (18) Audi S4 and S6
  • (31) AM General postal vehicles
  • (24) Alfa Romeo 164
  • (60) AMC Eagle
  • (53) Audi A8
  • (3,500+) BMWs including an M3, M5, Z3, 850i and (3) 740il Protection
  • (52) Cadillac Allante
  • (15) Cadillac Commercial Chassis/Limousines
  • (1,007) Chevy Camaro
  • (97) Chevy Corvette
  • (5) AWD Chrysler 300
  • (17) Chrysler Conquest
  • (39) Chrysler TC by Maserati
  • (3) Dodge Conquest
  • (6) Dodge Daytona
  • (210) Dodge Stealth
  • (16) Eagle Talon
  • (2) Federal Coach Lincoln Limo
  • (2) Ford Aspire (didn't these things get like 30 mpg?)
  • (855) Ford Crown Victoria CNG
  • (917) Ford Crown Victoria Police Interceptor
  • (14) USPS Ford Explorer
  • (24) Ford F-150 SVT Lightning
  • (1,611) Ford Mustang (so Mustang beats Camaro here)
  • (107) Ford Taurus SHO (don't tell Neff)
  • (15) Isuzu Vehicross
  • (1,047) Jaguars including (9) XJR, (2) XK8 and (96) XJS
  • (3) Laforza SUV
  • (6) Maseratis including a Biturbo and the 1985 Quattroporte
  • (373) Mazda RX-7
  • (5,000+) Mercedes-Benz including (142) SL, (3) S600, a 1994 E500, a 1992 500E, 1995 C36 and 1999 C43
  • (26) Merkur Scorpio and (21) XR4Ti
  • (187) Mitsubishi 3000GT
  • (3) Mitsubishi Eclipse and (4) Starion
  • (2) 1984 Nissan 200SX, (2) 1994 240SX and (381) 300ZX
  • (1,935) Oldsmobile Aurora
  • (22) Peugeot
  • (87) Pontiac Aztek (more please), (61) Fiero and (569) Firebird/Trans Am/Formula
  • (6) Porsche 928 including (2) S4
  • (6) Porsche 944
  • (597) Saab
  • (3) Saturn
  • (20) Sterling
  • (173) Subaru including (123) SVX
  • (327) Toyota Supra, including (4) final generation

http://www.autoblog.com/2009/09/24/shed-a-tear-for-clunkers-that-deserved-better/
 

Euro

GM or Nothing
Oct 22, 2007
20,450
641
Roselle
Real Name
Matt
I read on another board from a guy that's on a Turbo Buick site that the GNX was a pile. Here's his quote from my other board.

[Captain Ficho] says:
Yeah, it was junk though, anyone who follows gnxs knows that
It was more gn than gnx
It was totalled in 95 and all the shit was replaced with parts from a gn
And then buddy winter drove it from 95 to 05 and put it on eBay for 35k and nobody bought it
It was a rusted gn with a gnx number plate on the dash more or less


Grand Prix Ste Turbo
1990 - 5 (only 1,000 of these were made!!) :tear:

Grand Prix Turbo
1989 - 1

1990 - 3

Poor McLaren Turbo GP's :(
 

Oreif

Crazy Little Child
Oct 17, 2008
1,168
2
Schaumburg
Funny that after the first week of the C4C many reports were that the Ford Explorer and the Jeep Grand Cherokee models were the highest traded in vehicles and yet only 14 Explorers and no Jeep's are on the final list??????????? I don't even see a Ford Winstar or a Dodge Caravan on the list as well.

Remember this:
http://autos.yahoo.com/articles/aut.../top-cash-for-clunkers-trade-ins-and-new-cars

The Top Ten Cash for Clunkers Trade-Ins:
1. 1998 Ford Explorer
2. 1997 Ford Explorer
3. 1996 Ford Explorer
4. 1999 Ford Explorer
5. Jeep Grand Cherokee
6. Jeep Cherokee
7. 1995 Ford Explorer
8. 1994 Ford Explorer
9. 1997 Ford Windstar
10. 1999 Dodge Caravan
 

Primalzer

TCG Elite Member
Sep 14, 2006
25,259
61
I think this list concentrates more on the odd-balls, rather than the ones people know are going to be on there.

On second glance there are quite a few cars on there, that I would've gladly gotten in front of that person and given them more than the 3500 or whatever for that car. I mean the 500E would've been awesome. Or the C43, or the mitsubishi starion or chrysler conquest.
 

Oreif

Crazy Little Child
Oct 17, 2008
1,168
2
Schaumburg
I just hope most of these cars were either rusted up, dented to shit or totaled at some point. I wanna know which ones had salvage titles or clean titles.

Per the C4C website the cars could not have a "salvage" title.
But I agree many of the cars on the list had to have been in very bad shape to be worth less than the $3500/$4500 they got for it.
 
Old Thread: Hello . There have been no replies in this thread for 90 days.
Content in this thread may no longer be relevant. Consider starting a new thread to get fresh replies.

Thread Info