Make a piezoelectric crystal based sensor that responds to only a few specific vibration and sound frequencies running on 5v for less money.
I'll be waiting.
But there is your answer: knock sensors are actualy very precisely tuned measurement instruments, even a little off and they will read false, or not at all.
X2 on the connection. the knock sensor on the rear bank always gets messed with during a trans rebuild. GM actually released it with its own pigtail that can be replaced if damaged.